NPS has been at this since 2009. Seventeen years of hamster cages, glass cubes, and Liberals. So we did what any recovering scientist would do. We exported the whole pile and got Claude (Fable 5.2) to do some counting and analysis while we watched.
671 entries. 249 distinct hotels (the Marlowe alone shows up twenty times). 27 countries. 31 states if you count DC as a state, which any democracy should. Yowza!
But you probably don’t care about any of that. You probably just want to know where to stay. Fine. Here are the five best hotels on planet earth, according to seventeen years of home grown data (weighted slightly toward recent visits so the ghost of Kimpton past does not win):
- Hotel Monaco, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Six ratings, six fives.
- Hotel Christiania Teater, Oslo, Norway. Five ratings, five fives. The Oslo hotel of choice.
- Arimasansoh Goshobessho, Arima, Japan. Perfection. It says so right in the title.
- Ett Hem, Stockholm, Sweden. Worth a visit to Stockholm all by itself.
- The Peninsula, Tokyo, Japan. Five showerheads in 2017 and five again in 2026.
Now that you have what you clicked for, stick around. The data get more fun—especially if you are me.
Way back when, the post WTF is this blog about?! laid out the simple heuristic behind the whole thing: no plastic showers. Simple. And effective. But, as it turns out, we have been cheating on our own rule for almost two decades.
First, the somewhat embarrassing, but definitely accurate part. The best predictor of a showerhead rating is, in fact, not the shower; it’s the cocktail. Entries with a proper drink in them average 4.3 showerheads. Entries without? 3.6. More than half of the “cocktail featuring entries” score a five. Apparently a decent hotel bar papers over a multitude of sins.
Second, the rule bends. Nine hotels earned five showerheads with a shower curtain or a plastic cubicle in the room. The Marlowe got its first five “in spite of their generic showers” because the staff was the best in the business. The Onyx pulled the curtain liner out of our shower as a joke. Hilarious. Still, they both pulled fives. The Helix had no glass showers at all. Five. Great people beat good plumbing. Every single time.
Third, Kimpton. Kimptons make up 13% of the hotels and 47% of the fives. The Marlowe once got ten showerheads. Out of five. Then IHG ate them (last licks here). Here is the funny thing. The data say the hotels may never have gotten worse. Kimpton averaged 4.6 before the acquisition and 4.5 after. We just stopped caring. The Monaco in Pittsburgh is the lone survivor, and we liked it enough to get married there.
Marriott, meanwhile, averages 2.6. We rest our case.
Fourth, NPS has lived four lives (if we were a cat this would leave five more in the hopper…we are not a cat). The Cigital years: relentless work travel, one hotel in four abroad. The Synopsys years: half abroad, lots of Nuremberg, courtesy of the silicon valley corporation whose travel policies, frankly, sucked. Retirement in 2019: entries cut in half and Kimpton down to zero. And the Romey era: two of every three hotels brand new, and art everywhere. Through all four lives the average rating is 4.0. NPS is nothing if not consistent.
The tripometer agrees. Trips fell from an awful 42 in 2013 to 21 in 2015. Hotel entries stayed right around 40 a year. Fewer trips, more hotels per trip. Talks slid the whole time—right into home base.
A few more observations for the road:
- Two demotions in a row is fatal. Ask the Wilmington Hilton: three, two, one, one, zero. No hotel has ever come back from two straight demotions.
- Old friends fall too. The Cowper Inn in Palo Alto held a five for years and now sits at two. The Grant Street Inn in Bloomington, Indiana evolved right off the list. The Georgian in Santa Monica is the only real comeback story in the data.
- Norway averages a sad little 3.0 across nine hotels (sorry, Norway), even though Christiania Teater remains the Oslo hotel of choice and lands on our top 5 list. Japan averages an impressive 4.7. See Arimasansoh Goshobessho for an example of NPS perfection.
- Washington DC averages 4.6 across eight hotels, but since Kimpton shrank into a raisin we still have nowhere to stay by default. (Eaton, we’re looking at you.)
- “We’ll be back” turns out to be a coin flip. Nineteen promises kept, fifteen not. (Apologies to the Golden Well in Prague.)
Five showerheads for seventeen years of data and a at least two Liberals for anybody who read all 671 entries. Just remember the rule! NO PLASTIC SHOWERS (unless the bartender is really good)!
