Noplasticshowers by the Numbers: Seventeen Years of Showerheads
November 15, 2026
NPS has been at this since 2009. Seventeen years of hamster cages, glass cubes, and Liberals. So we did what any recovering scientist would do. We exported the whole pile and got Claude (Fable 5.2) to do some counting and analysis while we watched.
671 entries. 249 distinct hotels (the Marlowe alone shows up twenty times). 27 countries. 31 states if you count DC as a state, which any democracy should. Yowza!
But you probably don’t care about any of that. You probably just want to know where to stay. Fine. Here are the five best hotels on planet earth, according to seventeen years of home grown data (weighted slightly toward recent visits so the ghost of Kimpton past does not win):
- Hotel Monaco, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Six ratings, six fives.
- Hotel Christiania Teater, Oslo, Norway. Five ratings, five fives. The Oslo hotel of choice.
- Arimasansoh Goshobessho, Arima, Japan. Perfection. It says so right in the title.
- Ett Hem, Stockholm, Sweden. Worth a visit to Stockholm all by itself.
- The Peninsula, Tokyo, Japan. Five showerheads in 2017 and five again in 2026.
Now that you have what you clicked for, stick around. The data get more fun—especially if you are me.
Way back when, the post WTF is this blog about?! laid out the simple heuristic behind the whole thing: no plastic showers. Simple. And effective. But, as it turns out, we have been cheating on our own rule for almost two decades.
First, the somewhat embarrassing, but definitely accurate part. The best predictor of a showerhead rating is, in fact, not the shower; it’s the cocktail. Entries with a proper drink in them average 4.3 showerheads. Entries without? 3.6. More than half of the “cocktail featuring entries” score a five. Apparently a decent hotel bar papers over a multitude of sins.

Second, the rule bends. Nine hotels earned five showerheads with a shower curtain or a plastic cubicle in the room. The Marlowe got its first five “in spite of their generic showers” because the staff was the best in the business. The Onyx pulled the curtain liner out of our shower as a joke. Hilarious. Still, they both pulled fives. The Helix had no glass showers at all. Five. Great people beat good plumbing. Every single time.
Third, Kimpton. Kimptons make up 13% of the hotels and 47% of the fives. The Marlowe once got ten showerheads. Out of five. Then IHG ate them (last licks here). Here is the funny thing. The data say the hotels may never have gotten worse. Kimpton averaged 4.6 before the acquisition and 4.5 after. We just stopped caring. The Monaco in Pittsburgh is the lone survivor, and we liked it enough to get married there.
Marriott, meanwhile, averages 2.6. We rest our case.
Fourth, NPS has lived four lives (if we were a cat this would leave five more in the hopper…we are not a cat). The Cigital years: relentless work travel, one hotel in four abroad. The Synopsys years: half abroad, lots of Nuremberg, courtesy of the silicon valley corporation whose travel policies, frankly, sucked. Retirement in 2019: entries cut in half and Kimpton down to zero. And the Romey era: two of every three hotels brand new, and art everywhere. Through all four lives the average rating is 4.0. NPS is nothing if not consistent.

The tripometer agrees. Trips fell from an awful 42 in 2013 to 21 in 2015. Hotel entries stayed right around 40 a year. Fewer trips, more hotels per trip. Talks slid the whole time—right into home base.

A few more observations for the road:
- Two demotions in a row is fatal. Ask the Wilmington Hilton: three, two, one, one, zero. No hotel has ever come back from two straight demotions.
- Old friends fall too. The Cowper Inn in Palo Alto held a five for years and now sits at two. The Grant Street Inn in Bloomington, Indiana evolved right off the list. The Georgian in Santa Monica is the only real comeback story in the data.
- Norway averages a sad little 3.0 across nine hotels (sorry, Norway), even though Christiania Teater remains the Oslo hotel of choice and lands on our top 5 list. Japan averages an impressive 4.7. See Arimasansoh Goshobessho for an example of NPS perfection.
- Washington DC averages 4.6 across eight hotels, but since Kimpton shrank into a raisin we still have nowhere to stay by default. (Eaton, we’re looking at you.)
- “We’ll be back” turns out to be a coin flip. Nineteen promises kept, fifteen not. (Apologies to the Golden Well in Prague.)
Five showerheads for seventeen years of data and a at least two Liberals for anybody who read all 671 entries. Just remember the rule! NO PLASTIC SHOWERS (unless the bartender is really good)!
Grant Street Inn Evolves Right OFF the List
August 28, 2024
We’ve been coming to the Grant Street Inn since the year that it opening (in 1993). Sadly, not many improvements have been made in that time. LOL.
The latest and last trip in August 2024 was the last straw. No more Grant Street Inn.





We requested room 31, and ended up with some disaster of a room on the second floor. Oopsie.
One showerhead and a warning NOT to stay here if you can help it. Nope. All loyalty drained from the loyalty pool.
Bloomington Done Right: The Grant Street Inn
January 17, 2020
You know how we feel here at NPS when it comes to generic hotels. The good news is that this trip (off season and not on a game weekend) the Grant Street Inn had our favorite room available. Needless to say, this place beats the heck out of the Hyatt Place.

So here we are in room 31. Sadly the fireplace has been disconnected and no longer functions. In fact, there are a few things that could use sprucing up…like better furnishings, no ancient radio, no phone that plugs into the wall, and some outlets built into the bedside table. You can do it guys!!




Hey now @GrantStInn what is this wired up beige thing and/or this plastic cup thing? Not to mention the (unplugged) clock radio. In fact, what is radio?
Asking for a time traveler. pic.twitter.com/teOAksrpHK
— noplasticshower (@noplasticshower) January 17, 2020
The first trip of 2020 started out great with a last minute upgrade from United who seems to have changed their upgrade policy to make things more nail biting for Global Services members. Not sure how we feel about that.


And then there was the hilarious stretch limo that the car service used to get us from Indy to Bloomington.


While in Bloomington, visit the Irish Lion for a stiff drink. And have some food at Anyetsang’s Little Tibet Restaurant.
Bloomington @theirishlion pic.twitter.com/tv4VOd4g6e
— noplasticshower (@noplasticshower) January 17, 2020
The Grant Street remains our favorite location to stay in Bloomington. Four showerheads.
Switcheroo at Grant Street Inn Bloomington, IN
October 1, 2015
I have been coming to the Grant Street Inn for about twenty years ever since they opened. They know me, and theoretically they know that I am a big fan of room 30. Alas, on this trip they put me in room 31. The room is nice, but its biggest feature is also its biggest flaw.
The problem with 31 is noise from the 7th Street bus route. It’s OK during the day, but it starts early. Room 30, just around the corner from the pod is much quieter. And room 30 has a fireplace and a nice shower thing with a hot tub feature.
The door to the outside deck is very nice. And the deck makes a great place to delete email as big buses rumble by.
The shower in 31 is reasonable. It is a cube with glass, but not as fancy as it could be.
While in town, try restaurant DO for some interesting Korean food.
Anyway, for forgetting that I really prefer room 30, the Grant Street gets a temporary three showerheads. Until next time!
Yes, we know the governor of Indiana is a jackass. And as a serious participant in the Indiana business community, my company is not happy with the exclusionary stupid laws recently enacted. But it’s not like we can just pull up stakes and leave. So we sometimes have to go to Indy.
You need a new less stupid governor indiana pic.twitter.com/a4XMhVDmJQ
— noplasticshower (@noplasticshower) April 18, 2015
Last trip out, NPS gave the Alexander a shot with mixed results. This time, we found a better room (3044) and had a much better shower. Much less hamster cage. Much more bathroom kung fu. If we find a higher floor version, we will have what we actually want. Oh, and about that morning newspaper…
Not only was the shower glass, it had great shower pressure and plenty of hot water. YES!
I was so beat when I got to the Alexander, that I did not even go to the fabulous bar for a night cap. Slept like a log. Maybe next time.
Four shower heads for the Alexander. So much better than the awful Conrad!
In other Indianapolis news, other than a stupid jackass governor, the Libertine has moved to new fancier and hipper digs. Still the same great cocktails though.
Benjamin @LibertineIndy mixing a cocktail. New location is gorgeous. pic.twitter.com/rHmLIwN0Ar
— noplasticshower (@noplasticshower) April 16, 2015
Arriving too early for the event and just in time to squeeze in a cocktail, my companion and I were served by Benjamin Moran. After the event, three hours later, we returned for more. Here is the as yet un-named Libertine Experiment One:
2 oz Ford’s Gin
.5 Cocchi Torino
.5 Gran classico
.25 Dry curaçao
1 dash angostura
2 droppers scorpion grapefruit tincture (in house)
Stir down. Big rock. Grapefruit peel garnish for nose.
Benjamin was nice enough to make this for me even though his shift was over. But not to fear, Colin Lime was in the house to take over. Colin made us an Indiana Diamondback:
2 oz Bonesnapper Rye (local)
.75 Green Chartruese
.5 Demerara syrup (1:1)
2 dashes Angostura
3 dashes lemon bitters
shake. serve over big rock. lemon peel garnish.
Then it was back to Bloomington and the Grant Street Inn, but not before stopping in at the Irish Lion again for a Sazarac with Hendry.
Sazarac made right @theirishlion by kim french. pic.twitter.com/YI4m4Slt1J
— noplasticshower (@noplasticshower) April 16, 2015
As a creature of habit, I always look forward to returning to my favorite haunts. The Grant Street Inn is my Bloomington home away from home. And room 30 is my room…though they changed it up!
Traveling at the height of Spring in Virginia is a tough row to hoe, but at least it is the height of Spring here too!
Four perpetual shower heads forever. Plus a garland of flowers.
Very sad Bloomington news though, the Rail has closed. This leaves precisely zero high end mixology bars in town. So it will be the Irish Lion for some bourbon I suppose. So bummed.
Dinner at Janko’s.
Grant Street Inn Bloomington, IN
September 27, 2013
There have been so many visits to this fine property over so many years (almost all in room 30) that I will skip the pictures this time.
Here’s a VINE posting from the porch
https://vine.co/v/h67KvDvH0TU
If you stay anywhere in Bloomington, Indiana, stay at the Grant Street Inn. Four perpetual showerheads forever.
In other news, the Irish Lion has a very nice selection of decent bourbon. Rumor has it, they will have a shipment of antique collection bourbon soon. Meanwile, rye concoctions with Handy Sazarac Rye are available.



























RSS - Posts